알리야의 싱글이며 그녀의 2집 앨범
One in a Million의 다섯번째 싱글로 1997년 8월 25일에 발매되었다.
2. 오디오/뮤직 비디오[편집]
[Intro] Hey, oh Yeah [Chorus] How could the one I gave my heart to Break my heart so bad? How could the one who made me happy Make me feel so sad? Won't somebody tell me, so I can understand If you love me, how could you hurt me like that? How could the one I gave my world to Throw my world away? How could the one who said, "I love you" Say the things you say? How could the one I was so true to just tell me lies? How could the one I gave my heart to Break this heart of mine, tell me [Verse] How could you be so cold to me? When I gave you everything All my love, all I had inside How could you just walk out the door? How could you not love me anymore? I thought we had forever, I can't understand How could the one I shared my dreams with Take my dreams from me? How could the love that brought such pleasure Bring such misery? Won't somebody tell me, somebody tell me please? If you love me, how could you do that to me, tell me Whoa, hey [Bridge] Yeah, how could you just walk out the door? How could you not love me anymore? I thought we had forever Can't understand No I can't understand [Chorus] How could the one I gave my heart to (Oh) Break my heart so bad? (Break my heart) How could the one who made me happy (You made me so happy) Make me feel so sad? (Oh, yeah) Won't somebody tell me? (Won't they tell me?) So I can understand (So I can understand) If you love me, how could you hurt me like that? (How could you hurt me?) How could the one I gave my world to Throw my world away? (Throw my world away) How could the one who said, "I love you" (You said you love me) Say the things you say? (But you didn't love me, oh) How could the one I was so true to (Yeah, you did) Just tell me lies? (You told me lies, oh yeah) [Outro] How could the one I gave my heart to (Ooh) Make me feel so sad? (Hey) How could the one I gave my heart to Break my heart so bad? Tell me (tell me, tell me) Ooh, tell me
|
빌보드 R&B 차트에서 8위,
빌보드 핫 100에서 1997년 11월 셋째 주부터 넷째 주까지 2주 연속 9위를 기록했고 3주 연속 10위권에,
[5] 15주 연속 20위권에,
[6] 1997년 10월 둘째 주부터 1998년 1월 셋째 주까지
17주 연속 40위권에 머물러 있었다.
[7] 1997년 10월 첫째 주부터 1998년 1월 넷째 주까지
1997년 빌보드 R&B 연말 차트에서 73위,
1997년 빌보드 핫 100 연말 차트에선 78위, 1998년 빌보드 R&B 연말 차트에서 83위,
1998년 빌보드 핫 100 연말 차트에선 86위에 올랐다.